Where to Sell Beanie Babies for Money: 4 Places

Have Beanie Babies and need some cash? Let’s look at where to sell Beanie Babies for money below!

One of the first big internet crazes, Beanie Babies took the world by storm in the 90’s and were a hot collectible by grown ups and kids alike. Despite different reboot attempts over the years, these toys have never returned in popularity. However, the original toys that are still in existence can be very valuable if you have the right editions.

If you still have Beanie Babies or have inherited them from someone else, you may be wondering if the Beanie Babies that you have are valuable?

The good news is that you can still sell Beanie Babies for cash. Prices do vary from a few dollars each to hundreds or even thousands of dollars each. The current value depends on the rarity, the type and the condition. Here are some of the places to sell Beanie Babies for money.

Where to Sell Beanie Babies for Money: 4 Top Websites

While there are places you may be able to sell your Beanie Babies locally, like many collectibles, most selling and buying in this space takes place online.

Selling your collectibles online helps you reach a wider selection of buyers. It can also help you streamline your sales process if you have a large collection you are looking to sell.

Below are some of the top websites that can help you in the sales process and help you fetch you the best prices for your Beanie Babies.

1. eBay

eBay is a top choice for selling almost anything and has been a market leader for collectibles for multiple decades. Doing research on eBay can also help you to begin knowing the worth of your Beanie Babies.

With over 300,000+ Beanie Babies for sell on eBay, this site can give you an idea of going rates for items that are similar to those in your collection. Prices vary from pennies to thousands of dollars for each toy. However, when doing your research be sure to see what items are actually selling for. The actual purchase amounts are the current market values are often much different than the asking price on many listings.

2. Etsy

While Etsy is known primarily for selling homemade and handcrafted items, they do sell some collectibles as well. If you do a quick search you can see Beanie Babies for sale online for a few dollars to a few thousand dollars.

3. Sell2BBNovelties

A popular collectible selling site, Sell2BBNovelties does buy and sell Beanie Babies as well as other popular items. If your Beanie Babies collectible (or other valuable) is over $30 in value, there is free shipping and there are no seller fees for reselling through this site.

4. Selling Beanie Babies Near Me

If you’re looking to sell Beanie Babies locally, Craigslist and Facebook Marketplace can give you an opportunity to list the items online and sell to local buyers. These online swap sites offer a variety of items, so it may take some time to find the right buyers.

Be prepared to be patient and post your listing more than once if you need to in order to make a sale.

There are also Beanie Babies groups on Facebook where collectors buy, sell and trade.

Another place to try selling your Beanie Babies locally is at local antique shops. While pawn shops typically no longer accept these stuffed toys, antique shops that purchase and resell collectibles may have an interest.

If you have a particularly large collection, flea markets are another method of selling Beanie Babies locally. While you may have a few fees involved such as booth rental, you may be able to sell a large number of the collectible in a short period of time.

Tips for Selling Beanie Babies

If you’re selling Beanie Babies for the first time, it’s important to understand a bit about them. Other than their cute designs, there are other key factors to keep in mind.

Examine the Condition

If you’re looking to sell Beanie Babies, the condition of the collectible is important. The toy must be clean and free of marks or stains. It also should still have the tag attached. Beanie Babies without the tag are typically worth 50% less in value. Those Beanie Babies with errors on the tag such as typos can be extra valuable.

Look Up the Generation

Knowing what generation your Beanie Babies are is important in estimating their value. Use the Beanie Babies generation guide here to research your collection.

Allow Time For Sales

When selling your Beanie Babies collection, keep in mind that it may take time and work to find the right buyers. Even if you have rare editions, be prepared to do work for research. You may also need to try more than one listing method to make a sale.

Selling Beanie Babies for Cash

While Beanie Babies are no longer a worldwide craze, the collection you have at home can help you earn some extra cash. You won’t be able to retire on the sale of your collection; however, you can earn extra money for selling these vintage toys.

There are lots of places to sell Beanie Babies for cash both locally and online. To get the best price, take the time to inventory your collection, find out more about each collectible, and where you can earn the most for each toy.

Looking to sell some of your other collectibles? Here is where to sell Pokemon cards for cash.

Have tips for selling Beanie Babies that we missed? Leave a comment below!

Kim Ritter is a frugal living expert, blogger and mom of two from small-town Iowa. What began as an effort to help her family save a few dollars a month has now transformed into a full-time passion to help other parents money. Visit her online at twokidsandacoupon.com and follow her on Twitter at @2kidsandacoupon for more ways your family can have fun on a budget.